Public consultations, public policy

Ongoing infrastructure projects by local governments intended to serve the public often result in numerous complaints from those affected. In many cases, projects require extensive public consultations for various reasons. Recognizing the invaluable role of society in these processes is crucial to solving problems and supporting more inclusive decision-making.

To be effective, consultations must be tailored to the specific impact of the proposed project. Failure to engage key project stakeholders can lead to serious concerns and negative consequences that we must avoid.

The “Establishment of Pedestrianization at Osmeña Boulevard and Colon Street” in Cebu City is a perfect example of a project that was implemented without proper public consultation.

As a taxpayer and former government official, I wrote to Eng. Norvin Imbong and I would like to discuss my concerns regarding pedestrian traffic, particularly the potential impact on local businesses, traffic flow and safety. This pedestrian crossing is part of the port connection project of the Cebu Bus Rapid Transit (CBRT) project.

Was the pedestrian crossing project subject to public consultations? If so, when and which sectors were invited?

I question whether the city’s Department of Engineering and Public Works (DEPW) at Cebu City Hall and the business owners affected by the pedestrianization were consulted. Pedestrian closures could result in these establishments losing business, which could significantly impact the local economy.

I wonder what will happen to the delivery trucks and vehicles of consumers who shop at affected stores along the route. What drainage channels feed the ditches and what measures are taken?

Are affected jeepney drivers subject to public consultation? I doubt whether they have considered the scenario of a vehicle breaking down on a single lane “pedestrianized” street and what contingency measures are in place for such events.

There is also concern about who will keep the promenade clean. Would it fall under the jurisdiction of the barangay? It would be useful if the City Hall cleaned up its surroundings and the entire section of the pedestrian boulevard at the same time.

If an audio engineer can answer these questions in detail, I would be willing to support the project. However, I am concerned that such a pedestrian crossing will only jeopardize the safety of Cebuano drivers due to potential hazards such as streetlights installed in the middle of the road that may pose a collision risk or obstruction.

I am glad that after reviewing the complaints and photos of the lampposts, Cebu City Acting Mayor Raymond Alvin Garcia has ordered the immediate removal of the lampposts built in the middle of Osmeña Boulevard. But my biggest question is: why did he approve it in the first place? Engineer Imbong told Cebu media that the acting mayor approved the installation of the lanterns. Why oh why?

The investment, if not carefully planned and executed, may significantly waste government funds if the new mayor stops it in June 2025 and restores the road to its previous width. Potential financial losses and disruptions to city infrastructure are concerns that should not be ignored.

Engaging with communities before any formal consultation begins and in real time as it progresses is a great way to ensure that their perspectives and opinions are effectively incorporated into decision-making.

Incorporating technology into project implementation can significantly improve community engagement. By using various social media platforms to disseminate information and solicit feedback, we can complement face-to-face interactions and create a more holistic public engagement strategy at every stage of the process.

Generally established processes often generate high-quality recommendations because they require gathering valuable insights and making informed judgments through thorough consultations.

By engaging in comprehensive consultation with a broad range of stakeholders and carefully gathering diverse and valuable input, we are better equipped to develop evidence-based, context-specific policies that are relevant, effective, practical and implementable.

Our unwavering commitment to promoting transparency and accountability in government should be inextricably linked to our commitment to providing essential services.

Local governments should create an environment in which citizens gain power,