Treasury Issues Final Digital Asset Reporting Rules

June 28, 2024

Abstract virtual hologram of blockchain technology with handshake on Los Angeles skyline background. … (+) Digital Money Transfers and the Concept of Decentralization. Multiexposure

Getty

The Treasury Department and the IRS have released long-awaited final regulations on digital asset transaction reporting requirements. The rules, which will go into effect for transactions occurring in 2025, are intended to increase tax compliance in the rapidly evolving cryptocurrency space. But while some see the rules as a necessary step toward legality, others worry about unintended consequences for innovation and privacy.

Good: more transparency and a balanced approach

Supporters of the legislation say it will increase transparency in digital asset markets and help close the “tax gap”—the difference between taxes owed and taxes paid. By requiring brokers to report information on gross revenue and cost base on Form 1099-DA, the legislation should make it easier for taxpayers to accurately report cryptocurrency gains and losses.

“This legislation is an important part of a broader effort to improve tax compliance for high-income earners,” said IRS Commissioner Danny Werfel. “We need to make sure digital assets are not being used to hide taxable income.”

Some industry experts and lawmakers also praised the Treasury for taking a more balanced approach than earlier proposals. The final rules delay implementation until 2025, provide optional aggregate reporting for some stablecoins and NFTs, and exclude noncustodial (decentralized) brokers from the reporting requirements for now.

The Bad: Compliance Burdens and Privacy Concerns

However, critics argue that the regulations are still too broad and will impose significant compliance costs, especially on smaller brokers. The definition of “broker” remains broad, potentially encompassing entities with limited visibility into user transactions.

Privacy advocates have also raised alarm about the collection and storage of detailed transaction data, including wallet addresses. While the final rule removed the requirement to report transaction identifiers on 1099 forms, brokers are still required to collect and store the information for seven years.

Uncertainty: Impact on Innovation

Perhaps the biggest question is how the rules will affect innovation in the rapidly evolving cryptocurrency and blockchain space. Proponents say clear reporting guidelines will help legitimize the industry and attract institutional investors. But others worry that overly burdensome requirements could fuel offshore development or stifle emerging decentralized finance (DeFi) applications.

The Treasury’s decision to delay noncustodial brokerage regulations suggests regulators are still grappling with how to approach new blockchain technologies. As the cryptocurrency landscape evolves, finding the right regulatory balance remains an ongoing challenge.

Summary

While the final regulations address some industry concerns, they are likely to remain controversial as implementation approaches. Businesses and cryptocurrency users should familiarize themselves with the new requirements and consider how they may impact their operations and tax reporting obligations. In the meantime, lawmakers and regulators must continue to refine their approaches to encourage innovation while ensuring appropriate oversight of this new asset class.

As always, I recommend consulting with a qualified tax professional who can advise you on your specific situation.