Share buyback tax rules: How will the new rules affect capital allocation strategies?

From October 1, 2024, significant changes to the tax regulations regarding the purchase of own shares will come into force. The changes will shift the tax burden from corporations to shareholders, which is expected to have a profound impact on capital distribution strategies and investment decision-making processes.

This policy change was officially announced in the Union Budget 2024. Under the updated rules, proceeds from redemptions will be classified as ‘dividend’ income and not ‘capital gains’, changing the tax treatment of such transactions. Previously, buyouts were exempt from company taxation, but under the new regulations, shareholders receiving income from buyouts will be obliged to pay tax on these profits.

How much tax do I have to pay? Calculate now

According to experts, the introduction of new regulations on share buybacks will result in a significant transformation of the Indian tax system. This change will shift tax obligations from corporations to shareholders, which will have a profound impact on capital allocation practices and investment strategies.

“The new share buyback tax regulations, which will enter into force on October 1, 2024, will have a significant impact on corporate capital allocation strategies. These provisions introduce a transfer of the tax burden from companies to shareholders, treating the proceeds from the buyout of shares as a dividend that will be taxed at the shareholders’ level at “flat-rate income tax rates, and not the company paying the buyout tax at the rate of 23.92% (20% + 12% + 4%) under Section 115QA,” said Mohammed Chokhawala, tax expert at ClearTax.

Shareholders must adjust their tax returns for the repurchase proceeds because they were included in dividend income. This adjustment aims to level the playing field for dividends and buy-backs to create a fairer tax system. Shareholders may face higher tax liabilities depending on their income tax bracket, making it extremely important for investors to reconsider their strategies.

According to Chokhawal, in this way, tax laws will change the allocation of corporate capital

Improving capital efficiency: By shifting the tax burden of buybacks to shareholders, companies can redirect funds previously earmarked for buyout taxes. This allows for a more efficient use of capital, enabling investment in growth opportunities such as expansion, acquisitions and new product development.

Strengthened Financial Position: The decision to reinvest excess cash instead of using it for buyouts can improve a company’s financial position. This could result in strengthened balance sheets, better credit ratings and better financial metrics. Additionally, an improvement in the financial situation may result in a reduction in external financing costs, which will ultimately bring benefits to the company in the long run.

Emphasizing Retained Earnings and Investments: As shareholder taxes on buybacks increase, companies are turning to retaining retained earnings and funneling them toward more beneficial endeavors such as research and development, technological improvements, or debt repayment. This shift from direct shareholder benefits to long-term expansion can significantly improve a company’s performance and financial stability.

The updated regulations urge companies to adopt a strategic and growth-oriented capital allocation strategy, placing greater emphasis on long-term investments and targeted buyouts that generate sustainable shareholder value.